The Abundance Debate We’re Not Having


The best way to read Ezra Klein and Derek Thompson’s new book is to take the authors at their word. Abundance is what is usually called a “policy book,” but Klein and Thompson don’t quite offer a traditional policy agenda. Instead, the authors begin and end with a question that is also a concentrating lens. “Can we solve our problems with supply?” More broadly, if we focused our attention on expanding the provision of goods and services rather than fighting over who gets what, or who is winning or losing the culture wars, what might we learn?

The central problem of American politics, Klein and Thompson imply, is not conflict but the scarcity that fuels it. If we lived in a world of real material abundance—for example, where people had sufficient access to housing and the other resources necessary for a good life rather than just consumer goods—people would be less dissatisfied.

More at Combinations.

Other Writing:

Academic Article

Analytical Democracy: A Microfoundational Approach – with Hugo Mercier and Melissa Schwartzberg

Henry Farrell, Hugo Mercier and Melissa Schwartzberg (2023), “Analytical Democracy: A Microfoundational Approach,” American Political Science Review. 117,2:767-772. A prominent and publicly influential literature challenges the quality of democratic decision making, drawing on political science findings with specific claims about the ubiquity of cognitive bias to lament citizens’ incompetence. A competing literature in democratic theory ...
Read Article
Essay

In praise of negativity

Andrew Gelman has a post on the benefits of negative criticism, where he talks about the careful methodological demolitions he has done of others’ research that he has found to be slipshod. if you want to go against the grain you have to work harder to convince people. My point is that this is the ...
Read Article