Hybrid Institutions and the Law: Interface Solutions or Outlaw Arrangements?

Much discussion of law and e-commerce focuses on the extent to which e-commerce and the Internet weaken sovereign states’ effective control. Recently, in e-commerce, there has been a trend towards “hybrid institutions” which blend public oversight and private enforcement in the international arena. Do these institutions reflect the weakening of state legal orders, and the need of states to co-opt the “outlaws” in order to claw back some degree of control? Or alternatively, do hybrid institutions reflect the need of states to find interfaces between their very different systems of legal ordering when these systems are brought into conflict as a result of the expansion of e-commerce? In this article, I seek to evaluate these different accounts of hybrid institutions with regard to the EU-US Safe Harbor arrangement. I provide a detailed account of the Safe Harbor and its enforcement mechanisms. I show how Safe Harbor more closely reflects an interface solution than a weakening of the law per se. Safe Harbor presents a novel interface between two different legal systems, but relies extensively on the legal systems both of the EU and US, in order to lend it both meaning and back-up.

Henry Farrell (2002), “Hybrid Institutions and the Law: Interface Solutions or Outlaw Arrangements?,” Zeitschrift für Rechtssoziologie, 23, 1:25-40.

Access the full article here.

Other Writing:

Academic Article

Introduction: Blogs, Politics and Power – with Daniel W. Drezner

There is good reason to believe that blogs are changing politics, but we don’t know exactly how. Nor do we know whether the normative consequences of blogs for poli- tics are likely to be good or bad. In this special issue, we and our co-authors undertake the first sustained effort to map the empirical and ...
Read Article
Chapter in an Edited Volume

“Great Britain: Falling Through the Holes in the Network Concept,” in Local Production Systems in Europe: Rise or Demise? – with Colin Crouch – ed. Colin Crouch et al.

British economic development has long exhibited strong regional patterns and contrasts. The UK shares with France a characteristic not possessed by Germany or Italy: the contemporary weakness of its major regional centres, so that the capital cities (London and Paris) and the regions surrounding them (the so-called Home Counties in south-east England and the Ile ...
Read Article